Miller’s Family Dentistry Logo

(209) 835-5116

Cracked Tooth Conundrum: Root Canal vs. Extraction

Dentist cleans tooth canals of patient and removes nerve

Did you know that a cracked tooth can cause more than just discomfort? The decision between a root canal and extraction can be daunting, but understanding the benefits and drawbacks of each procedure is crucial for your oral health journey. When you face such a situation, deciding between tooth extraction vs root canal can leave you with a notable problem.

By comparing root canal vs tooth extraction, you can make an informed decision about preserving your natural teeth. Let’s explore these two treatments more.

What Happens When Your Tooth Cracks?

A cracked tooth often results in an infected pulp chamber. This infection can spread to the root canal, causing significant pain. Counter pain relievers may provide temporary relief, but a proper dental procedure will be needed to address the issue. Diagnosing a problematic tooth is a crucial stage in the treatment decision process. It helps determine whether a root canal treatment or tooth extraction is best for oral health.

What Is Root Canal Treatment?

Also known as endodontic treatment, a root canal procedure is typically preferred to preserve as much natural tooth structure as possible. This procedure involves the removal of the infected or dead pulp from the tooth, cleaning and disinfecting the inside, and then filling and sealing it.

Benefits of Root Canal Therapy

  • Preservation of the Original Tooth. This procedure lets you keep most of your natural tooth, maintaining your normal bite and oral functionality.
  • High Success Rate. Studies show that root canal treatment generally has a high level of success and durability, with results often lasting a lifetime.
  • Eliminates Severe Pain. The root canal procedure removes the cause of the pain, providing significant relief from severe pain and discomfort often associated with a cracked tooth.
  • Prevents Spread of Infection. By cleaning and disinfecting, root canal therapy prevents further spread of the infection to adjacent teeth or gums.

Drawbacks of the Root Canal Therapy

  • Longer Procedure. A root canal therapy typically entails one to three appointments, depending on the severity of the infection.
  • Post-Treatment Discomfort. Some patients report mild discomfort or sensitivity in the treated tooth following the endodontic procedure.
  • Possible Complications. In rare cases, a previously undetected crack in the root, a breakdown of the sealing material over time, or a new infection could lead to complications.
  • Potential for Repeat Treatment. After a root canal, the tooth may not fully heal or may become infected again, requiring further treatment or even extraction. This can not only be stressful but could also increase the overall treatment cost.

What Is Tooth Extraction?

A tooth extraction might be suggested when there’s not enough of the tooth left to support a crown or other procedure or if the decay is near the tooth’s pulp. If the tooth is compromising the health of other teeth or causing significant pain, pulling the tooth might be the best treatment option.

Benefits of Tooth Extraction

  • Infected Tooth. Tooth extraction eliminates an infected or severely decayed tooth, preventing the infection from spreading to neighboring teeth or other body parts. It is a viable alternative when a root canal might not be sufficient to save the tooth.
  • Rapid Healing Time. The basic tooth extraction healing process is quicker than a root canal. There’s typically less post-operative discomfort, and with proper oral hygiene, dry sockets and other complications are rare.
  • Healthy Blood Flow. If the tooth is severely decayed or infected, extraction can improve overall blood flow in the mouth. Removing problematic teeth can also lead to improved general health.
  • Tooth Extraction Costs. An extraction is generally less costly than a root canal treatment, which can involve additional procedures like a dental crown.

Drawbacks of Tooth Extraction

  • Missing Tooth. Extraction removes the entire tooth, which could lead to difficulties with eating and speaking. You may also need a dental implant or bridge for cosmetic reasons, adding to the total cost of treatment.
  • Dry Socket. This is an uncommon yet plausible issue that can occur post-extraction. It happens when the blood clot typically formed in the socket after extraction is displaced or breaks down prematurely before the wound healing, revealing the bone and nerves beneath it.
  • Potential Treatment Option. Although extraction is less expensive, it is ideally a last-resort treatment. Preserving your natural teeth is usually preferable, if possible.
  • Facial Swelling. Some post-operative swelling or discomfort is normal after an extraction, but excessive or prolonged facial swelling should be discussed with your dentist.

Root Canal vs Tooth Extraction: Factors to Consider

When weighing cracked tooth root canal vs extraction, there are several factors you need to take into account, including:

The Location and Health of the Tooth

The position of the compromised tooth plays a critical role in your decision. For instance, molar teeth that are less visible may be more likely candidates for extraction. The tooth’s health is also crucial. If the tooth damage or decay is so severe that it’s penetrated the pulp, leading to a severe tooth infection, a root canal may be necessary to alleviate pain.

Patient Comfort

Depending on your comfort levels, one of these procedures may seem more appealing. Typically, a root canal can cause more discomfort post-operation, but it relieves pain caused by an infected pulp. On the other hand, tooth extraction can cause fear in some patients despite being a fairly standard procedure. Understanding your comfort with these procedures is vital to making an informed decision.

Recovery Time

In most cases, the recovery time for an extraction is shorter than a root canal. The healing process after a cracked tooth’s extraction is relatively rapid, making it attractive to adults who need to return to their routine quickly. However, the recovery time may increase if the tooth extraction leads to complications, like a dry socket.

Long-Term Oral Health

A significant consideration is the long-term impact on your dental health. When adult teeth are extracted, it can sometimes cause nearby teeth to shift, disrupt the bite, and lead to more problems. While a root canal preserves the tooth and prevents such issues, there might be a chance of re-infection in the long run.

When Should You Consider Root Canal Therapy?

  • Persisting Severe Toothache. The significant time you should consider root canal therapy is when you have a persistent, severe toothache. Imagine enjoying your favorite meal when a sudden, sharp pain shoots through your tooth, ruining your appetite and making you wince in discomfort. Such experiences occur when the tooth pulp, which houses nerves and blood vessels, becomes infected or inflamed. A root canal procedure effectively removes the infected pulp, resolving your pain.
  • Tooth Sensitivity. If you’ve recently bitten into chilled ice cream or sipped a steaming cup of coffee and felt an uncomfortable, lingering sensitivity in one particular tooth, that could be another sign to consider root canal therapy. It’s like you’re looking forward to that first bite of your ice cream on a sunny day, only to be met with a sudden, sharp pain. A root canal would relieve this kind of sensitivity by treating the issue at its root.
  • Swollen or Tender Gums. Another reason to consider a root canal is if you notice swollen or tender gums around a specific tooth. Imagine you’re brushing your teeth in the morning and feel a tender spot while moving the toothbrush along the gum line. Swollen or tender gums often signal an underlying issue, such as an infection that a root canal could remedy.
  • Darkened Tooth. If you notice one of your teeth looking darker or becoming discolored, it’s time to consider root canal therapy. For instance, while preparing for a meeting and practicing your smile in the mirror, you notice that one tooth is a bit darker than the others. This could indicate that the nerves in the tooth are dead or dying—a problem that root canal therapy effectively addresses.

When Should You Have Your Tooth Extracted?

  • Severe Tooth Damage. Extraction may be the only option when a tooth has been severely damaged by decay or trauma. For example, if you’ve suffered a blow to the mouth while playing sports and your tooth cracked beyond repair, you may need to remove it. It’s important to note that your dentist won’t make this decision lightly, but sometimes, it’s necessary to protect your oral health.
  • Dental Crowding. Sometimes, you might lack sufficient room in your mouth for all your teeth. This is often the case with wisdom teeth, which can cause discomfort or misalignment as they try to break through the gums. Dentists often recommend extracting these ‘third molars’ to alleviate pain and avoid future issues.
  • Impacted Tooth. An impacted tooth is a tooth that can’t break through the gum line, either due to lack of space or abnormal growth angle. You’ll usually know when you have an impacted tooth; discomfort, inflammation, and difficulties with eating often accompany it. In many cases, it’s wiser and less painful to get the tooth extracted than to suffer from ongoing symptoms.
  • Deep Tooth Infection. Tooth infections that have spread deep into the tooth pulp may require extraction, particularly when root canal treatment won’t solve the problem or has failed. A common example here is a throbbing toothache that’s particularly sensitive to heat, cold, and biting pressure. This might be a sign of an abscess, a pocket of infection that’s very tough to eradicate.

Resolve Your Cracked Tooth Problem With Confidence at Miller’s Family Dentistry

Choosing between a root canal or tooth removal for a fractured tooth can be intimidating. Therefore, it becomes critical to study both options carefully, get expert opinions, and evaluate the pros and cons of each procedure. Whether you’re seeking to maintain as much of your natural teeth as possible or trying to solve the issue cost-effectively, know there is a suitable solution for every situation.

At Miller’s Family Dentistry, we pride ourselves on providing patient-focused dental care using the latest technology. Don’t hesitate to schedule your consultation today for a healthy, pain-free smile tomorrow. Contact us at Miller’s Family Dentistry to ensure your smile stays as vibrant as ever.

Dr. Ron Miller - Miller's Family Dentistry

About Dr. Ron Miller

I’m proud to be following in my family’s footsteps when it comes to providing families with quality healthcare. Dentistry has changed so much since my father opened this office more than 50 years ago. I take pride in bringing you the benefits of the latest advances for gentler, more effective care. But one thing hasn’t changed: We still offer the personalized care that makes every patient feel special.

Recent Posts